Tuesday, May 24, 2016

Franklin PUD Commission Opposes Initiative 732 (Franklin PUD, Pasco, WA)

(PASCO, WA) -- The Franklin PUD Commission unanimously passed a resolution today at its regularly scheduled board meeting opposing Initiative 732 that imposes an escalating tax on carbon emissions from electricity generated by fossil fuels.

A citizens’ group identifying itself as “Carbon Washington” (CarbonWA) has gathered sufficient signatures in 2016 to place Initiative 732 (Initiative), also known as the Carbon Pollution Tax Act, before the Washington State legislature.   By the end of the special session, the 2016 Washington State legislature chose not to adopt the original Initiative, which automatically sends it to the ballot before the Washington State voters in November 2016.  The Initiative is intended to encourage cleaner energy solutions by taxing, per ton, carbon dioxide (CO2) pollution from fossil fuels.

If passed, the Initiative would impose an escalating tax on the carbon emissions from the electricity generated by fossil fuels, including electricity generated within, imported into Washington, or acquired from the Bonneville Power Administration (BPA).  The Initiative proposes a $15 tax per metric ton (PMT) of carbon dioxide emissions beginning July 2017, increasing to $25 PMT in July 2018 and increasing 3.5%, plus inflation annually thereafter up to a $100 PMT limit.

“This tax will be imposed on the consumer of electricity, our Franklin PUD customers, then the tax will be collected by Franklin PUD and remitted to the State’s general fund with no clear path that guarantees a reduction in carbon emissions”, stated Roger Wright, Franklin PUD Commission President. The administrative and reporting requirements in the Initiative will result in increased staff time, the cost of which is not currently determinable.

This is taking place while Franklin PUD already provides over 90% of our electricity to customers that is carbon free - thanks to hydro, wind, and nuclear power. 

Of main concern to Franklin PUD is that the utility is being required to use the Washington State Fuel Mix report as compiled by the Department of Commerce.  This report has been proposed to be the basis in determining the monthly carbon tax on Franklin PUD customers.  According to the Initiative, the percentage of Franklin PUD’s fuel mix that comes from an “unspecified resource” will be considered coal, regardless of its source - which could be from hydro, wind, solar, nuclear or other sources. The Initiative assigns a carbon liability for market purchases of electricity made by BPA and is included in the electricity Franklin PUD buys from BPA, which is about 85% of Franklin PUD’s power purchases.  Market purchases are made by BPA when there’s a need for more electricity, which often occurs during times of lower hydropower generation.   

Franklin PUD customers would incur additional costs from the Initiative mandates estimated to be between $1,880,000 and $3,164,000 annually when fully implemented.  The cost is projected to vary depending on how much hydropower is available and the need for market purchases.   


Franklin PUD will continue to work with other utilities on carbon reduction solutions.